Page: 6 of 6
Travel Sites: Ratings of Sources
Total of 18 Sources

For an explanation of how we rank reviews, see our ratings criteria page.

1. J. D. Power and Associates
Nov. 25, 2008
2008 Independent Travel Website Satisfaction Study
by Editors of J.D. Power & Associates
Our Assessment

This report relates travelers' overall satisfaction with seven independent travel websites when booking airline, hotel or car reservations. Hotwire.com receives the highest rating overall, performing particularly well in the areas of competitive pricing and site navigation. Priceline.com lands in second place, with competitive pricing a strength. Expedia.com, Travelocity.com, Orbitz.com and Hotels.com earn scores just slightly lower than Priceline.com's, while CheapTickets.com ranks significantly lower in overall satisfaction. This survey does not rate travel search engines like Kayak.com, which search multiple travel sites.

expand

collapse

30 Best Travel Sites
by Stacy Rapacon
Our Assessment

Kiplinger's Stacy Rapacon says, "We've personally used each of these sites to research and book travel and found them superior to others." In the airfare category, Kayak.com is rated best for time-pressed travelers. However, other sites such as cFares.com score better with international travel. Farecast.com gets high marks for scouting out best airfare deals faster than other sites, which is helpful for flexible travelers. In the lodging category, Priceline.com offers the best deals in luxury hotels, according to editors. And LastMinute.com (formerly Site59.com) does the best job of ferreting out last-minute vacations -- even three hours before departure time.

expand

collapse

3. The Washington Post
Feb. 3, 2008
54 Online Travel Sites to Bookmark Now
by Michael Shapiro
Our Assessment This compilation of travel sites focuses mainly on sites that offer special discounts or bargains, although some other specialty sites are included. Reviews of each are fairly brief, but are broken down by category. Standouts among general travel sites include Orbitz.com, Expedia.com, Kayak.com, Sidestep.com and BookingBuddy.com.
4. Travel and Leisure
Dec. 2008
T+L's Top Travel Websites of 2008
by Cliff Kuang, Bree Sposato and Jennifer Welbel
Our Assessment

The reporters assemble a list of what they consider to be the top websites of 2008, along with a brief description of their individual strengths. Sidestep.com and Kayak.com get nods as the best tool for booking flights and hotels. They are called the "ultimate source for deals on airfare, hotels and car rentals." The best site for researching low-fare carriers in Europe is Wegolo.com. TripAdvisor.com is called the best destination for user reviews of hotels, restaurants and attractions.

expand

collapse

5. Lifehacker.com
Nov. 2, 2008
Five Best Travel Sites for Cheap Tickets
by Adam Pash
Our Assessment Reviewer Adam Pash conducts a brief and "completely unscientific" test of the bargain-hunting capabilities of five popular travel sites and discusses the results. Although Pash's comparison of a single round-trip flight between Los Angeles and Omaha is by no means conclusive, the differences in each site's search capabilities will probably interest many prospective air travelers.
6. PCMag.com
Aug. 25, 2008
The Top 100 Classic Web Sites: Travel and Maps
by Kyle Monson
Our Assessment

PCMag.com names the top websites in more than a dozen categories, including travel. Selections are drawn from nominations by a committee of editors and analysts. Top consideration is given to sites that are "either regularly adding cool features, or started out so unimprovably perfect that they shouldn't ever change." Kayak.com is named the best comparison travel site for 2008, while TripAdvisor.com is called "the best way to scout out a hotel from a thousand miles away before booking your room."

expand

collapse

7. PCMag.com
Aug. 11, 2008
The Top 100 Undiscovered Web Sites: Travel and Maps
by Kyle Monson
Our Assessment

This list of top websites focuses on those "that capture the best of the trends and memes swirling around the Web." Farecast.com uses ticket-pricing trends to identify the best time to buy an airline ticket. InsideTrip.com includes more parameters -- such as legroom and aircraft type -- to the flight searches offered on other travel search engines. TripIt.com will build a master itinerary for you from your confirmation emails.

expand

collapse

8. PracticalHacks.com
Oct. 6, 2008
The Ultimate List of Top Travel Sites
by "Kevin"
Our Assessment This aptly-named list of travel sites is extensive, though there's not a great deal of discussion given to any one site. Sites are conveniently separated and accessible by type, however, and site descriptions do contain a few interesting details not readily offered by other reviewers. A few graphics illustrate certain points of interest.
9. PC World
Feb. 2, 2009
Travel Sites Venture Beyond the Bottom Line
by Janet Fullwood
Our Assessment

This overview article moves past the well-known travel comparison and booking sites to focus on smaller sites that fill in niches in travel planning. Sites highlighted include ones that select your travel destination for you based on a based on your personality or interests, such as BestTripChoices.com. DealBase.com brings hotel deals and offers together in one place. Compete4YourSeat.com lets you build a trip and receive bids from competing travel agents. Other examples are given, and no site is specifically recommended.

expand

collapse

10. PC World
July 19, 2007
Best Travel Planning Sites
by James Martin
Our Assessment Martin recommends four travel sites in this older roundup. Farecast.com gets the nod because it charts airfares for a particular itinerary. Kayak.com lets you search for hotels, cars and cruises as well as revealing the price that other users have gotten. ITA Software.com "is a good option for finding the lowest airfares." No specific recommendations are made, though.
11. Miami Herald
Nov. 4, 2007
''Big Three'' Booking Sites
by Editors of the Miami Herald
Our Assessment

This older article provides a snapshot view of the "big three" online book sites -- Expedia.com, Orbitz.com and Travelocity.com. Opinions are based on company-supplied information as well as the newspaper's unspecified research. Details such as booking fees, fare alerts, the availability of last minute deals, customer support and more are listed. Expedia.com is called the favorite of the three because of its "appealing, easy-to-use home page and tools."

expand

collapse

12. Travel and Leisure
March 2008
Best New Airline Web Sites
by Wing Sze Tang
Our Assessment Seven sites are listed and briefly described in this article, which focuses primarily on air travel. Momondo.com is one of the few search engines discussed; reviewer Wing Sze Tang appreciates Momondo's ability to search more than 450 different sites to find the cheapest flights. Yapta.com is also recommended for bargain hunters looking to score the best prices on airfares.
13. Los Angeles Times
Jan. 21, 2009
These Websites Help You Choose the Right Cruise Ship
by Vani Rangachar
Our Assessment This article gives advice on who should -- and should not -- book a cruise online, and then lists the top websites for booking a voyage. Each capsule review includes information about what makes the site worth visiting. Sites are not rated or recommended, however.
14. CNBC
Dec. 15, 2008
On The Money: The Best Travel Websites
by Carlo Dellaverson
Our Assessment

Carlo Dellaverson lists these travel sites, favorites of NBC travel editor Peter Greenberg. None are reviewed in great detail, but they do represent an interesting cross section of the types of travel resources available on the Web. Yapta.com and AirfareWatchdog.com are the top choices for air travelers, while BedandBreakfast.com and LuxuryLink.com cater to different niche markets. Tripit.com is named as an excellent option for organizing itinerary details.

expand

collapse

15. MSNBC
Dec. 11, 2007
6 Essential Sites for Planning a Family Cruise
by Amber Nolan
Our Assessment

If you are planning a cruise -- especially a family cruise -- this article details sites that can help make the many decisions involved a lot easier. Amber Nolan details which sites do what best -- from finding deals and discounts to picking a cabin to planning shore excursions. All of the sites are described in generally positive terms, however, and the article gives the impression that a visit to all six is a necessity.

expand

collapse

16. Viewpoints.com
As of May 2009
Travel Web Site Reviews
by Contributors to Viewpoints.com
Our Assessment

This site solicits reviews from users of dozens of travel-related websites, including major aggregators such as Orbitz.com and Expedia.com. Many of the resources listed have only a handful of reviews, but a fair number have amassed a significant volume. A five-star rating system also allows visitors to see at a glance how well a particular site stacks up. Among sites with 20 or more ratings, TripAdvisor.com and Kayak.com receive the highest averages.

expand

collapse

17. The New York Times
Sept. 30, 2007
When the Best Deals Don't End in .Com
by Michelle Higgins
Our Assessment

Many big travel sites also have offshoots in foreign countries like Mexico or Germany, and these offshoots typically charge lower airfare and car rental fees, says The New York Times' Michelle Higgins. Because companies have multi-tiered pricing structures, the rates for cars and planes (not hotels though) can vary considerably from those published in the U.S. The upshot is that if you're traveling within a country, it makes sense to search foreign version of travel websites first before booking.

expand

collapse

18. Yahoo.com
Nov. 27, 2007
New Generation of Travel Web Sites
by Megan K. Scott
Our Assessment For those interested in exploring something other than the big travel sites, Associated Press writer Megan K. Scott provides this brief rundown of alternative travel sites such as Vayama.com, Yapta.com, Boo.com, and VibeAgent.com (now Hotelicopter.com). Sites aren't rated, however, and no one site is recommended over any other.

Back to top