Voice Calls from Gmail

Free to U.S. and Canada
Reviewed
October 2010
Google Voice

Best Free VoIP

Pros
  • Free calls to all phones in U.S. and Canada
  • Integrated with Gmail contacts
Cons
  • Variable voice quality
  • No 911 service
  • Must call from computer in U.S.
  • May not remain free after 2010

Reviews say Google's new free VoIP service, Voice Calls from Gmail, beats Skype at one very important thing: You can call any landline or mobile phone in the U.S. or Canada for free. (To receive incoming calls, you'll need a Google Voice number, also free.) The person on the other end doesn't have to have any special equipment or tech savvy -- just a normal phone -- while Skype calls are only free if the person on the other end has equipped their computer or mobile phone with Skype software. However, reviews say Skype is still better for overseas calling: Gmail calls only work if you're in the U.S., and Gmail charges extra for all international calls, whereas Skype allows you to talk for free anywhere in the world.

Gmail does do a couple of other things Skype can't do. It allows you to easily click-and-call your Gmail contacts from within Gmail, and you can get a free Google Voice phone number that will ring on all of your phones (including your Gmail) and consolidate all of your voice mail, too. Google will also transcribe your voice mails for free, and then email or text them to you, but testers say the voice mail transcription often garbles the messages. Like Skype, you cannot call 911, plus you cannot place a VoIP call from Gmail on a mobile phone (only on your computer, for now), and Google has not promised that the service will remain free after 2010.

CNET compares Voice Calls from Gmail directly with Skype, and testers declare that Gmail calling is better in most ways. PC World also compares the two and finds Gmail calling's features more valuable than Skype's. The New York Times, PCMag.com and Laptop Magazine also test Voice Calls from Gmail, with varying results.

Our Sources

1. CNET

Voice Calls from Gmail beats Skype in this head-to-head comparison. It wins in all categories -- features, apps and interface, device compatibility and cost -- although testers say Skype is still the better international option.

Review: Prizefight: Google Voice vs. Skype, Editors of CNET, Sept. 14, 2010

2. PC World

Barbara E. Hernandez likes Voice Calls from Gmail better than Skype -- as long as Gmail calling remains free, or at least cheaper than Skype. She likes that Google allows you to use one number for all of your phones and allows you to easily click and phone your Gmail contacts.

Review: Five Ways Gmail Chat Looks Better than Skype, Barbara E. Hernandez, Aug. 25, 2010

3. The New York Times

This blog post does a great job explaining what you can and cannot do with Google's Voice Calls from Gmail feature. You can't call 911, you can't call free outside of the U.S. or Canada and you can't call from a mobile phone -- but you can start a call on your computer and then transfer it to your mobile phone.

Review: Six Things Google's Free Phone Service Can't Do (and One It Does Very Well), Paul Boutin, Aug. 27, 2010

4. The New York Times

Voice Calls from Gmail are clear -- even on regular laptop speakers and microphones -- and easy to use, David Pogue says. He says it will be particularly exciting if this feature is ever offered on smartphones.

Review: Google Shakes It Up Again with Free Phone Calls, David Pogue, Aug. 26, 2010

5. PCMag.com

When Mark Hachman tests Voice Calls from Gmail, one call refuses to connect and another has poor sound quality. He says the feature "remains a curiosity," and that it can't replace a regular phone.

Review: Hands On: Google Voice Calls via Gmail, Mark Hachman, Aug. 25, 2010

6. Laptop Magazine

Eric Chiu explains how Gmail calling works and briefly tests it. Gmail's call quality is "consistently decent," and better than on an HTC Droid Incredible phone, Chiu says.

Review: Hands-on with Gmail VoIP: Gmail Adds the Kitchen Sink, Eric Chiu, Aug. 26, 2010

VoIP Runners Up:

Skype Free Skype-to-Skype

3 picks including: The New York Times…

Phone Power! *Est. $15 per month and up

3 picks including: Calling-Plans.com, My Rate Plan…

Back to top