Conventional Washers

Conventional top-loading washing machines

Old-style top-loaders aren't as sexy as the more stylish high-efficiency front loaders or top loaders, but they still have some advantages. Although less efficient, they are easier to repair because they use common parts and mechanisms (though backordered parts could always throw a wrench in repair times). We still read complaints about breakdowns for conventional top-loading washers, but at least they cost less at the outset.

A good basic top loader in reviews is the GE WJRE5500GWW (*Est. $525), a 3.5-cubic-foot capacity washer. This standard top loader has dial controls, 18 wash cycles, four temperature settings and automatic temperature control. It also has an automatic load balancer -- unusual on machines in this price range. At the time of our visit, we found almost 60 reviews for this GE washer at Sears.com, where its average rating is 3.2 stars (out of five) -- slightly better than other models in its price range. About a dozen owners at AJMadison.com give this washing machine an average of 4.4 stars (out of five) and a handful of comments at HomeDepot.com are very positive. High points include the roomy capacity and low noise. We read typical complaints about breakdowns, but the most consistent complaint is that this washer's spin cycle isn't particularly strong, so clothes may need more drying time.

The GE WWSE5240GWW (*Est. $400) is another good washer that performs a bit better than similarly priced models in reviews, and owners seem generally satisfied. As with all washing machines, however, we did read reports about repairs. This standard washer has a 3.2-cubic-foot capacity -- a bit less than the GE WJRE5500GWW -- and it has a plastic tub instead of stainless steel, but it costs a bit less and still has a load balancer. It has dial controls and a range of the usual cycles and options.

Whirlpool, which also manufactures Maytag, Roper, Estate and Inglis washing machines, has recently discontinued many highly rated conventional top-loading washers. Although Maytag has added a few new conventional washers to its lineup, none have been professionally tested yet and there is very little owner feedback available. The 3.2 cu. ft. Inglis ITW4300SQ (*Est. $340) is still manufactured, and we did find about 40 reviews for this model at BestBuy.com, where it receives an average of 3.3 stars (out of five) -- better than most cheap washing machines. Nearly all owners are pleased with the washer's performance, especially considering its price, but there are quite a few complaints about noise. We saw very few complaints about reliability. Inglis washers are primarily sold in Canada, but a few models are sold in the United States through Best Buy.

Conventional top-loaders may be a dying breed due to new efficiency standards, so if this is your preferred style of washer, you might want to buy one within the next few years.