Wet / Dry Vacuums: Ratings of Sources
Paul Johnson and the editors at FineHomebuilding.com put eight wet-dry vacs through three rigorous tests: sucking up concrete mix, drywall dust and a mixture of sawdust and nails. The shop vacuums range in size from 10 to 30 gallons, and six of the eight are tool-activated. All eight models either come with or are compatible with HEPA filters and disposable filter bags. Johnson recommends five of the eight models, but one of his picks is discontinued.
Roy Berendsohn and his team test six small wet-dry vacs, around 3 gallons in capacity. They time each model as it picks up two pounds of sawdust, two pounds of screened top soil and one gallon of water. A brief write-up lists pros and cons for each vacuum, but there's no direct comparison between models, and no explicit ratings.
While some content at FineWoodworking.com is restricted to members only, you can read a number of reviews of tool-actuated shop vacuums at FineWoodworking.com. Testing is hands-on and fairly thorough. Reviewers don't provide any explicit ratings, but they outline each shop vacuum's strengths and weaknesses. However, some of the reviews are quite old.
ProToolReviews.com reviews all sorts of workshop tools, including tool-activated wet-dry vacs (dust extractors) and cordless utility vacs. You have to search a little to find appropriate articles, taking care to separate the actual reviews from news and product announcements. Some reviews are more rigorous and complete than others, but all include at least an overall rating of a shop vacuum's capabilities. Some of the older reviews cover products that are no longer available.
Amazon.com sells hundreds of wet-dry vacuums, from mini to massive in size, and some popular models receive hundreds of comments from users. We found three models with ratings of at least 4.5 stars from 500 users or more. Owner-written reviews vary in length and detail, but they provide useful info about durability and usability problems that may not be apparent during professional testing.
HomeDepot.com has over a hundred wet-dry vacuums for sale, and several models have hundreds of owner-written reviews. The most popular wet-dry vacs here are all from the Ridgid brand; we found several Ridgids with 4.5-star ratings from at least 350 users. In addition to its overall rating, each wet-dry vac receives ratings for quality, value and features. The site also notes what percentage of users would recommend the product.
Dan Ward puts four wet-dry vacs under $100 to the test by cleaning up various common messes: grinder dust, metal shavings, water and "the crud off of new floor mats." He also factors in cord and hose length, noise, capacity, suction power and other features to evaluate each vacuum. He doesn't list model numbers, however, so it's a bit hard to identify the recommended shop vacuums.
A contractor tests out four compact wet-dry vacs (between 4 and 5 gallons in capacity) at a job site and shares his impressions. No top model is explicitly named, but a brief write-up highlights each wet-dry vacuum's strengths and weaknesses. Two of the four vacuums are no longer available, however.
ConsumerReports.org no longer tests wet-dry vacuums, but it has ratings on its website for 23 shop vacuums it has tested in the past. Each one gets ratings for wet and dry pickup performance, emissions and ease of use, as well as an overall rating. Some of the editors' top picks have been discontinued, but similar models are often available.
Sears.com is the best place to find user feedback on Craftsman wet-dry vacs – a brand sold exclusively at Sears. In fact, all the top-rated models here are made by Craftsman, including six that have 4.5-star ratings from 150 owners or more. Reviews can be sorted by age, rating and helpfulness.
Lowes.com has a smaller selection of shop vacuums than HomeDepot.com, and the products it sells don't have nearly as much feedback from owners. We found only two wet-dry vacs, both Shop-Vac models, with more than 100 reviews total. Moreover, the individual reviews are generally pretty short.