Coupes Reviews

Google
  Web ConsumerSearch.com   
Reviewing the Reviews Home Category Index Shop Newsletter Search About Us

Coupes Reviews

Best Coupes Reviews: (out of 17)
Edmunds.com, Consumer Guide.com, Consumer Reports

Best Coupes: (out of 30)
2007 Honda Civic, 2008 Audi TT, 2007 BMW 3 Series 335i

Fast Answers - Best Coupes
Top Rated What the Research Says
•  2007 Honda Civic
   (*est. $14,810 to $23,040)

>> Where to buy

Best budget coupe.

The Honda Civic coupe is somewhat of a chameleon. In its lowest (DX) trim line, it is one of the least expensive coupes available. In its sporty Si trim line, it offers performance tuning and an upgraded 197-horsepower engine, and sports a suspension package and 17-inch wheels. Aside from the Si, the Civic is also one of the most environmentally friendly non-hybrids available, with EPA estimates of 30 mpg/city and 40 mpg/highway (using 2007 EPA standards). The 2007 Civic coupe is virtually unchanged from the 2006 redesign; apparently that's a good thing, as the car continues to draw raves from critics and consumers. (compare prices)
•  2008 Audi TT
   (*est. $34,800 to $41,500)

>> Where to buy

Top performance coupe.

The Audi TT (a 2008 model that has been released early) has been completely redesigned, transforming an also-ran into a top contender. While it still won't please sports-car purists, critics say it's a much easier car to live with on a day-to-day basis. In addition, testers say it handles weather conditions -- such as rain and even snow -- that would send most sports cars to the sidelines. Two versions are available -- a 200-horsepower coupe with front-wheel drive or a 250-horsepower coupe with Audi's quattro four-wheel drive system. Unlike a lot of performance cars, safety is not an afterthought, and the car comes standard with stability control, antilock brakes, a bevy of airbags and a powered rear spoiler that deploys automatically above 75 mph. Like a lot of performance cars, however, the rear seat is useless for adults. (compare prices)
•  2007 BMW 3 Series 335i
   (*est. $40,800)

>> Where to buy

Best luxury coupe.

While critics say the BMW 3 Series 335i coupe can more than hold its own in the performance category, it trounces its competition when it comes to sheer creature comforts. Build quality is first rate, and luxurious touches abound, especially if you spring for the optional leather seating. The seats are firm but comfortable -- both in the front and in the back -- for the long or short haul. Unlike some performance coupes, the rear seats are quite useable, though leg and shoulder room are a bit tight. There are no such issues in the front, however, as seat and steering wheel adjustments can accommodate even tall drivers. Performance, aided by the 335i's twin-turbocharged 3.0-liter engine, is first rate, as is handling. (compare prices)
•  2007 MINI Cooper
   (*est. $18,050 to $21,200)

>> Where to buy

"Cute" coupe.

British design and German engineering have teamed up in the Cooper and Cooper S to deliver a charming though tiny ride whose popularity has even surprised parent company BMW. Critics and consumers love its unique look and superior response and handling. Despite higher horsepower engines that are part of a 2007 refresh, power is adequate but not outstanding. Though it is one of the smallest cars on the road, reviews say it does a surprisingly good job with the available interior space, though passengers won't want to spend too much time in the back seat. In addition to the upgraded engines, the 2007 Cooper is just slightly larger than earlier versions and has updated cabin styling. (compare prices)
>>  Comparison Chart

Full Story
What the experts say, our analysis, and more...
Updated July 2007

We saw lots of great reviews of coupes for this update. Edmunds.com has extensive experience reviewing cars, and it shows in their well done and very complete reporting. Editors clearly identify which cars they think are best by segment -- including one for coupes -- and readers can rate cars and share their opinions as well. Consumer Reports is a bit short on discussion, but provides long-term reliability data on cars that's hard to find anywhere else. Consumer Guide does a great job of providing objective ratings in a number of critical areas and of letting readers know how those ratings stack up against similar cars. Car and Driver and Motor Trend magazines provide details and first-person reporting that's unmatched by most other reviewers, but don't do as complete a job of providing rankings and tend to concentrate more on higher-end performance and luxury coupes.

Coupes are two-door cars that span the gap between four-door sedans built for comfort and practicality and two-door sports cars and roadsters that are usually anything but practical or comfortable. In fact, many traditional sports cars are coupes. What differentiates them from the cars covered here are performance, comfort and cost. While many coupes are sporty, they don't quite have the horsepower or handling chops to compete with true sports cars, though some come quite close. Some high-performance and luxury coupes also come close to sports cars in cost, though most are much more affordable. Finally, the coupes we discuss here are typically more practical for everyday use. They offer more comfortable rides, a modicum of storage space -- or lots of hauling flexibility in the case of hatchback coupes -- and even honest-to-goodness back seats that adults can use (though some might not be that comfortable doing so). If you are interested in coupes that provide the maximum in sports car handling and performance, check out the ConsumerSearch report on sports cars for top-rated models.

While a lot of the flash and sizzle is in performance or luxury coupes, entry-level coupes designed to provide basic -- and sometimes more than basic -- transportation get lots of attention as well. Coupes like the Scion tC (*est. $15,000 to $17,200) and ultra-budget-priced Toyota Yaris (*est. $11,150 to $12,050) get their fair share of accolades. One economy choice -- the coupe version of the Honda Civic (*est. $14,810 to $23,040) -- is by far the most recommended coupe, though some of that is on the strength of its sporty and more costly Si trim line. The high cost of fuel is also helping to drive the interest in economy coupes, as many offer above average or better gas mileage.

Not all budget-priced coupes hit the mark, however. Though it is now ten years old -- and there are lots of them on the road -- the Volkswagen New Beetle (*est. $17,180 to $ 18,255) gets little respect from critics. While the car received an upgrade in 2006, introducing a 150-hp, 2.5-liter 5-cylinder engine that critics say was a welcome improvement, it is still an older design that's been largely eclipsed by more modern cars.

Edmunds.com notes that, all in all, the New Beetle is a decent car; it's just that there are better choices. They say cars like the Honda Civic or even Volkswagen's Rabbit (*est. $14,990 to $16,065) "provide better utility, driving dynamics and features." Part of the appeal of the car is its iconic styling; however, that styling also is the root of some real ergonomic issues, especially for any passengers unfortunate enough to find themselves in the rear seat. Specifically, Kelley Blue Book (kbb.com) points out that while the high dome provides a great 38 inches of headroom for the front-seat occupants, "the sloping hatch creates a nearly unusable rear seat." They add that the design also creates some "massive" blind spots around the windshield pillars. Even among so-called "cute coupes," critics say that the New Beetle has been outclassed -- particularly in the handling department -- by the MINI Cooper (*est. $18,050 to $21,200) .  ... Continued
Consensus Report

Our Consensus Report shows how many times products are top-ranked by reviewers included in our
All The Reviews Reviewed chart.

# of Picks Model (with retailer links) Details from Edmunds.com
7 Honda Civic (*est. $14,810 to $23,040) details
5 MINI Cooper (*est. $18,050 to $21,200) details
4 Audi TT (*est. $34,800 to $41,500) details
4 BMW 3 Series 335i (*est. $40,800) details
3 Scion tC (*est. $15,000 to $17,200) details
3 Toyota Yaris (*est. $ 11,150 to $12,050) details
3 Infiniti G35 (*est. $31,450 to $34,050) details
2 Honda Accord (*est. $20,475 to $27,500) details
1 each Hyundai Accent , Pontiac G5 , Mercedes-Benz CL-Class , Volvo C30 (2008) , Volkswagen Rabbit

Regardless of your budget or reason for wanting a coupe, there are plenty of good options available. Among those is the Honda Civic, whose many trim lines fill niches for those wanting inexpensive transportation, an environmentally friendly non-hybrid or a pulse-quickening sports car experience without the compromises -- or expense -- most sports cars demand. The MINI Cooper and Cooper S deliver a head-turning "cute" coupe that, while not the most powerful car on the road, is a blast to drive. For those craving the utmost in performance in a car that's more suitable for day-to-day driving, the new Audi TT gets some recognition. Finally, if you crave luxury and performance, it is tough to top the BMW 3 Series 335i coupe.

Advertisement
Coupes Reviews