USED CARS - Pickup Trucks Reviews

Google
  Web ConsumerSearch.com   
Reviewing the Reviews Home Category Index Shop Newsletter Search About Us

USED CARS - Pickup Trucks Reviews

Best USED CARS - Pickup Trucks Reviews: (out of 13)
Car and Driver, Car and Driver, Motor Trend

Best USED CARS - Pickup Trucks: (out of 23)
2006 Honda Ridgeline, 2006 Toyota Tacoma, 2006 Ford F-150

Fast Answers - Best USED CARS - Pickup Trucks
Top Rated What the Research Says
•  2006 Honda Ridgeline
   (*est. $27,700 to $34,640)

>> Where to buy

Small pickup truck.

Making its debut in 2006, the all-new Honda Ridgeline wins a slew of awards, especially for interior comfort, a car-like ride and the most comfortable back seat in its class. Other compact trucks like the Toyota Tacoma are better off-road and for towing, but the Ridgeline is the most car-like truck. Reviews especially like its lockable trunk, situated under the sturdy, watertight truck bed. The Ridgeline is powered by a 255-horsepower V-6 engine with all-wheel drive and can tow up to 5,000 pounds. Fuel economy isn't anything special, about 16 mpg/city and /21 mpg/highway. The Ridgeline has a four-door cab with seating for five. The rear seat splits 60/40 for additional cargo flexibility.
•  2006 Toyota Tacoma
   (*est. $13,780 to $25,615)

>> Where to buy

Mid-sized pickup truck.

According to reviews, the Toyota Tacoma is more truck-like than the Honda Ridgeline. Its interior isn't quite as comfortable, and it isn't as fun to drive, but the Toyota can tow 1,500 pounds more than Ridgeline and has a longer 74-inch truck bed (compared to the Ridgeline's 60-inch bed). There are 18 different variations available, including regular, extended-cab and double-cab body styles, short or long beds, 2 or 4-wheel drive, and 4-cylinder or V-6 engines. The Toyota Tacoma truck does not compromise its high level of quality and reliability, and it is slightly more powerful and fuel efficient (20mpg/city and 26mpg/highway) than its main competitor, the Nissan Frontier.
•  2006 Ford F-150
   (*est. $24,020 to $32,005)

>> Where to buy

Full-sized pickup truck.

The best-selling truck in America for the past 29 years, the Ford F-150 continues to win critical praise as well, for a comfortable interior and solid fit and finish. Critics praise the Ford F-150 for combining comfort and style with utility, smooth engines and upscale interiors. When properly equipped, the Ford trucks can tow five tons. The F-150 has a more car-like ride than the slightly rougher Nissan Titan. The F-150 is the also only vehicle in its class to earn NHTSA's 5-star rating for driver and right-front-passenger frontal crash safety, as well as receive a "Best Pick" in frontal offset crash testing performed by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS).
•  2006 Nissan Titan
   (*est. $26,250 to $35,900)

>> Where to buy

Full-sized pickup truck.

In reviews, the Nissan Titan runs neck-and-neck with the Ford F-150. The Titan is not quite as refined as the Ford, but its more powerful standard 5.6-liter V-8 engine makes up for a slightly rougher ride. In some roundups, reviewers say the Titan finishes slightly ahead of the Ford among four-door trucks. Having four full-sized doors adds weight to a pickup -- weight which the Titan handles better than the Ford, according to comparison tests. The Nissan truck and the Ford F-150 get identical fuel economy estimates of about 14 mpg/city and 19 mpg/highway.
>>  Comparison Chart

Full Story
What the experts say, our analysis, and more...

The following report was originally published on ConsumerSearch to cover new trucks manufactured and sold in the 2006 model year, and so can offer a good guide as to which cars from past model years are good bets as used vehicles. We are keeping this report on our site as a convenience to our readers who may be shopping for a used truck.

We found many good-quality reviews about pickup trucks, but three articles are standouts, two from the editors of Car and Driver and one from Motor Trend. Car and Driver magazine regularly evaluates pickup trucks on factors like comfort, cornering, off-road ability, towing capacity and a variety of acceleration measures. It also evaluates less quantifiable factors such as styling. Motor Trend conducts similar tests, and its 2006 Truck of the Year award is the result of a seven-truck torture test. We also found excellent pickup-truck reviews from InsideLine.com, an offshoot of Edmunds.com. Consumer Reports has some good information on pickup trucks, but you have to be a subscriber to read it. Kelley Blue Book, Consumer Guide and Yahoo! Autos are helpful sites for reviews, pricing and features information, but editors don't compare trucks to each other as much as Car and Driver and Motor Trend.

Though originally designed as workhorses, pickup trucks are increasingly being used to haul people. Thus, many newer models seek to address some traditional pickup shortcomings, such as acceleration, passenger comfort and interior room, while still delivering the towing and payload capacity that originally made pickups popular.

As a result of the new trend of increased passenger comfort and ergonomics, some older stalwart pickup trucks suffer in comparison to the Toyota Tacoma, Honda Ridgeline, Ford F-150 and Nissan Titan. These include the large trucks manufactured by General Motors -- the Chevrolet Silverado, Avalanche and Colorado, as well as the GMC Sierra. However, GM trucks can carry up to six people as well as a lot of gear, and they can be configured to haul more than 15,000 pounds.

According to Motor Trend, the Chevrolet Silverado 1500 (*est. $28,135 to $34,810) ranks last in comparison to the Nissan Titan , Toyota Tundra , Ford F-150 and Dodge Ram 1500 , with the Titan being the clear favorite. Editors say the Silverado pickup truck has a "soft" suspension, making it difficult to handle bumps and corners. Additionally, editors say that the Silverado's mostly plastic trim -- even on fully optioned models -- adds to an outdated interior. The Silverado is still a recommended model in several pickup truck reviews, including Consumer Guide, but it cannot surpass the achievements of the newer Ford F-150 and Honda Ridgeline . According to industry analysts, the Silverado is set for a 2008-model year redesign, which may address some of these shortcomings. In recent government crash tests, the Chevrolet Silverado and GMC Sierra got four-star ratings for protecting the driver in a frontal collision. They received lower three-star ratings for protecting the front-seat passenger. ... Continued  ... Continued

Consensus Report

Our Consensus Report shows how many times products are top-ranked by reviewers included in our
All The Reviews Reviewed chart.

# of Picks Model (With Retailer Links) Prices from Shopping.com
6 Honda Ridgeline (*est. $27,700 to $34,640)
4 Toyota Tacoma (*est. $13,780 to $25,615)
4 Dodge Ram (*est. $20,900 to $51,810)
4 Ford F-150 (*est. $24,020 to $32,005)
4 Nissan Frontier (*est. $27,200 to $29,950)
4 Nissan Titan (*est. $26,250 to $35,900)
4 Toyota Tundra (*est. $26,250 to $35,900)
2 Dodge Dakota (*est. $23,190 to $28,300)
2 Chevrolet Silverado (*est. $28,135 to $34,810)
1 each Ford Ranger , Mazda B-Series , Subaru Baja , Chevrolet Avalanche , Dodge Ram SRT10 , GMC Sierra , Dodge Ram Mega Cab , Mitsubishi Raider , GMC Canyon , Isuzu i350 , Lincoln Mark LT , Chevrolet Colorado

The Honda Ridgeline is the most notable new compact pickup for 2006, say reviews, but last year's favorite, the Toyota Tacoma , is also a highly rated compact truck in reviews, with better scores for off-roading and hauling. The Ridgeline scores big points for interior comfort and it's under-bed lock box. The Nissan Frontier fits somewhere in the middle of the two. Among full-size trucks, the Ford F-150 is Car and Driver's pick of the year, but the Nissan Titan continues to command good reviews.

Advertisement
USED CARS - Pickup Trucks Reviews