Answering Machines Reviews

Google
  Web ConsumerSearch.com   
Reviewing the Reviews Home Category Index Shop Newsletter Search About Us

Answering Machines Reviews

Updated December 2007

Best Answering Machines Reviews: (out of 6)
Amazon.com, Consumer Reports, Consumer Guide.com

Best Answering Machines: (out of 10)
GE 29869GE2, AT&T 1722

Fast Answers - Best Answering Machines
Top Rated What the Research Says
•  GE 29869GE2
   (*est. $35)

>> Where to buy

Best answering machine.

This GE unit, according to reviews, is the best choice if you want good voice quality, four separate mailboxes and a long, 40 minute recording time. The GE has a voice time/day stamp, an LED light which displays a number of messages, a scan feature which allows you to play the first five seconds of a message (helpful for finding the message you want in a crowded mailbox) and a battery backup so you don't lose messages in a power outage. Reviewers find that the GE gets better scores than most for voice quality. (compare prices)
•  AT&T 1722
   (*est. $17)

>> Where to buy

Basic answering machine.

The inexpensive AT&T 1722 has 19 minutes of recording -- shorter than that of the GE 29869GE2. But the AT&T answering machine does have power-outage protection so you don't lose messages. This model also has remote access (for getting your messages on the road), audible message alerts and a time/day stamp. You can also review messages in various speeds, useful for skipping through old messages or retrieving a number. You don't get two-way recording or caller ID display, and according to some reviews, voice quality isn’t always good, but the low price is a plus. (compare prices)
>>  Comparison Chart

Full Story
What the experts say, our analysis, and more...
Updated December 2007

Standalone answering machines are quickly becoming obsolete. About three companies currently manufacture these devices, so the pickings are slim. Even so, many officially discontinued models are still available. More popular these days are cordless phone/answering machine combos, which are covered in our companion report on cordless phones .

Consumer Reports magazine last updated its coverage of answering machines in 1999, and most of the included models have since been discontinued. Rather than Consumer Reports, we found opinion websites to be most helpful in lieu of professional reviews. When it comes to answering machines, owner satisfaction hinges primarily on voice quality and ease-of-use. We found the best owner-written reviews at Amazon.com and Epinions, along with some retail sites that also allow owners to leave comments for products -- CircuitCity.com and BestBuy.com.

Digital answering machines have completely taken over the market from the older varieties that record on tapes. Digital answering machines are faster and quieter, and they let you bounce from message to message, picking and choosing which messages to keep or discard. You also don't have to worry about finding replacement tapes.

While some AT&T answering machines get good reviews, we found mainly negative comments for the AT&T 1718 (*est. $25) . Of about 15 contributors to Amazon.com, not one owner gives it more than a single star. Some owners report that this model simply stopped working. Others are more specific; one user notes that he was able to program the day and year, but not the month. Another reviewer notes that voice quality is garbled. Instead of an LCD displaying the number of messages, this machine merely blinks (for example, if it blinks five times, you have five messages), hardly a convenient feature. Lastly, because the phone cord is hardwired to the machine, you'll need to buy a coupler if you need the phone cord to be longer than six feet. Other models solve this issue by simply having an input jack, so that you can use a phone cord of any length.

ConsumerSearch receives a number of inquiries from owners who have lost the manual to their answering machines. The best source we've found is www.InstructionSheets.com. This website has a large archive of owner's manuals available online or links to where you can find them. This is a great resource if you have a perfectly good answering machine but can't quite remember how to program it.  ... Continued

Consensus Report

Our Consensus Report shows how many times products are top-ranked by reviewers included in our
All The Reviews Reviewed chart.

# of Picks Model (With Retailer Links) Details from Amazon.com
2 GE 29869GE2 (*est. $35) details
2 AT&T 1738 (*est. $22) details
2 AT&T 1722 (*est. $17) details
1 each AT&T 1726 , AT&T 1739

The GE is a good choice if you need long recording time and multiple mailboxes. The AT&T 1722 receives good reviews as a budget model. The AT&T 1738 is similar, but costs a bit more.

Advertisement
Answering Machines Reviews