Portable Generators Reviews

Google
  Web ConsumerSearch.com   
Reviewing the Reviews Home Category Index Shop Newsletter Search About Us

Portable Generators Reviews

Updated February 2008

Best Portable Generators Reviews: (out of 17)
Consumer Reports, Camping Life Magazine, Field & Stream

Best Portable Generators: (out of 30)
Coleman Proforce PM0103000, Honda EU1000i, McCulloch FDD210

Fast Answers - Best Portable Generators
Top Rated What the Research Says
•  Coleman Proforce PM0103000
   (*est. $350)

>> Where to buy

Budget midsize portable generator.

If you need a portable generator mainly to power a fridge and a few lights in the event of an outage, and you don't care much about noise, the Coleman Proforce gets good ratings from homeowners. The voltage generated by the Coleman isn't especially consistent -- so it's not the best choice for powering a computer or sensitive electronics, but for other appliances and lights, this Coleman model should be fine. The Coleman generator is very loud, but it does have low-oil shutdown, which can save the generator if oil gets too low. A fuel gauge is also included. The control panel includes two 120-volt outlets and a circuit breaker.
•  Honda EU1000i
   (*est. $790)

>> Where to buy

Best-quality small portable generator.

Although it is expensive, the 900-watt Honda EU1000i has several advantages. Because it uses inverter technology, its voltage is consistent in quality, reducing risk of damage to sensitive electronics. Because it is small, lightweight and quiet, the Honda portable generator is also great for camping trips. The throttle adjusts engine speed to the electrical load for the best fuel economy. Included are two AC outlets and one DC outlet.
•  McCulloch FDD210
   (*est. $550)

>> Where to buy

Best value, small generator.

Unlike most budget models, this 1,600-watt portable generator uses inverter technology for quiet, consistent electricity -- making it a better choice for powering computers and sensitive electronics. Like the pricier Honda EU generator, the McCulloch model shuts down automatically if the oil level gets too low. It's also quiet enough to be used at a campground. However, the McCulloch guzzles more gas and has more emissions than others. It has one AC and one DC outlet. (compare prices)
•  Briggs & Stratton 030244
   (*est. $1,000)

>> Where to buy

8,000-watt portable generator.

If you need electricity to power an entire house (or most of it), reviews recommend the Briggs & Stratton Elite series for good power quality, and this large model uses a commercial engine with cast-iron sleeves and full-pressure lubrication for longer life. This also means less maintenance, changing oil every 100 hours instead of every 24 hours. A 30-amp cord is included, with four outlets on the end for your appliances. This model doesn't offer inverter technology, but large inverter generators cost more than $4,000.
•  Generac Guardian 04582
   (*est. $2,000)

>> Where to buy

15,000-watt portable generator.

Like the Briggs & Stratton 030244, this big electric start generator uses a Generac V-twin OHV engine with cast-iron sleeves and full-pressure lubrication for long life. The Guardian 04582 includes a 50-amp AC outlet for running an air conditioner. Reviews say this model can easily provide backup electricity for an entire house -- especially when equipped with a transfer switch. Auto-idle adjusts the engine to four speeds according to the load, but owners say this generator can really guzzle fuel. Wheels are included but, at 450 pounds, it strains the definition of portable. (compare prices)
>>  Comparison Chart

Full Story
What the experts say, our analysis, and more...
Updated February 2008

Portable generators provide electricity off the grid -- for camping, boating, RV use, building sites and for household electricity during power outages. Permanently installed standby generators are the fastest growing market segment -- with sales growing five-fold between 2000 and 2005. However, portable generators cost less and provide more flexibility for multiple uses. You can run a blender at a tail-gating party one day or run your home refrigerator when your power is down the next day.

We found the best review of portable generators at Consumer Reports, where editors rank eleven models (along with four stationary generators) based on objective testing. This review is one of the few that grades generators not only for ease of use and runtime per tank of gasoline, but also for the quality of the electricity produced -- that is, the consistency of the voltage. Reviews say that consistent voltage is important not only for running a computer, but also for other household electronic devices such as ranges and even fluorescent light bulbs.

Reviews in both Camping Life and Field & Stream magazines compare small portable generators -- light enough to hand carry to a campsite or tailgate. These generators can also power a few appliances for household backup, and the best can be daisy chained together for higher wattage. Reviews at Popular Mechanics and Black Enterprise magazines include bigger portable generators for emergency electricity, but neither magazine documents any testing. Neither do editors at ElectricGeneratorsDirect.com, but the site does recommend portable generator models as "good, better and best" in four different size ranges -- based on editors' judgments of quality, features and price; the ratings are supplemented by customer feedback.

Portable generators are made in series that share similar features, but vary in size and wattage. Reviews give top ranking to the Honda EU series of portable generators, followed by the Yamaha EF models that also use inverter technology and "smart throttles" for fuel economy. Briggs & Stratton Elite generators don't use inverter technology or auto-idle, so they're louder and less fuel efficient, but reviews rank them higher than Troy-Bilt or Craftsman portable generators, which in turn outperform Coleman models. For high wattage portable generators, reviews recommend engines with full-pressure lubrication, good for an average of 3,000 hours of use, three times as long as the average portable generator.

More expensive standby generators are more convenient and last about 15 years, while budget portable generators last an average of seven years. However, experts say that most homeowners use a generator only about 20 hours a year, so an inexpensive portable generator, if well maintained, may be just fine. We found dozens of owner-written reviews praising inexpensive portable generators for getting them through natural disasters and power outages without a hitch.  ... Continued

Consensus Report

Our Consensus Report shows how many times products are top-ranked by reviewers included in our
All The Reviews Reviewed chart.

# of Picks Model(With Retailer Links) Details from Amazon.com
4 Honda EU2000i (*est. $1,100) -
3 Honda EU3000is (*est. $2,000) -
3 Generac Guardian 04582 (*est. $2,000) details
3 Yamaha EF2400iS (*est. $1,200) details
3 Honda EU1000i (*est. $790) -
2 Briggs & Stratton EXL 30244 (*est. $1,000) -
2 Briggs & Stratton Elite 30242 (*est. $1,000) -
2 Briggs & Stratton 30241 (*est. $800) details
2 Troy-Bilt 30245 (*est. $700) -
2 Coleman Powermate PM0435001 (*est. $600) details
1 each Blue Max 1250w , Coleman Powermate Pulse 1800EX , Coleman Powermate Pulse 1850 , Coleman Powermate 8000 Electric Start , Coleman Proforce PM0103000 , Craftsman Briggs & Stratton Electric Start 030298, Craftsman 30250 (now 30332), Craftsman Briggs & Stratton 030251, Cummins Onan HomeSite 5500 , Makita G6100R , McCulloch FDD210 , NorthStar 165926 , Northstar Trifuel 165938 , NorthStar Trifuel 165939 , Troy-Bilt 030248, Troy-Bilt 30343, Yamaha EF30ISEBH

Portable generators at both size extremes get the most recommendations in reviews. The Honda EU and Yamaha EFi generators use "smart throttles" and inverter technology for fuel economy, quiet performance and very consistent voltage. The 15,000-watt Generac Guardian 04582 is the most recommended model in its size range. Among mid-sized portable generators, Briggs & Stratton takes the lead, with Troy-Bilt and Coleman as budget picks.

Advertisement
Portable Generators Reviews