Wood Routers Reviews

Google
  Web ConsumerSearch.com   
Reviewing the Reviews Home Category Index Shop Newsletter Search About Us

Wood Routers Reviews

Updated November 2007

Best Wood Routers Reviews: (out of 31)
Wood Magazine, Taunton's 2008 Tool Guide, Popular Woodworking

Best Wood Routers: (out of 65)
Triton MOF001KC, Bosch 1619EVS, Milwaukee Body Grip 5615-21

Fast Answers - Best Wood Routers
Top Rated What the Research Says
•  Triton MOF001KC
   (*est. $200)

>> Where to buy

Best plunge router overall.

Reviews praise this 12-amp Triton plunge router not only for great dust control and self-releasing collets, but for convenient bit changing and depth adjustments even when mounted in a router table (it can also be used handheld). As a plunge router it can start grooves or cuts safely in the middle of a board, so it's versatile. Its soft-start motor and light weight (a little over 10 pounds) make it easier to use freehand than a bigger router. It carries a three-year warranty. If you work with hardwoods or need a continuous duty router, you'll need a larger, more powerful router like the Bosch 1619EVS, however. (compare prices)
•  Bosch 1619EVS
   (*est. $310)

>> Where to buy

Best heavy duty plunge router.

Reviews give this 3.25-horsepower Bosch wood router top ranking in its size range, praising its soft-start variable-speed motor, dust control and self-releasing collets. Despite its 13.3-pound weight, reviews say this router maneuvers well for handheld use, yet also works well mounted in a router table. The large base opening and 2.56-inch maximum depth make it usable with large bits. It comes with a one-year warranty. (compare prices)
•  Milwaukee Body Grip 5615-21
   (*est. $155)

>> Where to buy

Fixed-base wood router.

If you don't need to do plunge work, a fixed-base router costs less and can be easier to learn to use. This single-speed, 1.75-hp Milwaukee wood router lacks dust control, but does have self-releasing collets, so bits are easily changed. Reviews recommend it as an excellent choice as a first router. It's designed so you can hold it with one hand, and at 8.8 pounds, it's lighter than most. When mounted on a router table, reviews say height adjustment is still easy. Like most Milwaukee tools, it comes with a five-year warranty. (compare prices)
•  DeWalt DW618PK
   (*est. $240)

>> Where to buy

Router combo kit.

Woodworking router combo kits combine one motor with two bases: a fixed base for table-mounted and trimming work and a plunge base for cutting grooves in the middle of a work piece. Although comparative reviews rank two other wood routers higher overall (see our full report for details), this 2.25-hp DeWalt router has a three-year warranty and a better track record for durability. Reviews praise its dust control and easy adjustments, bit changes and depth adjustment. The maximum depth is 2.5 inches, deep for a mid-sized router. (compare prices)
•  Skil 1825
   (*est. $100)

>> Where to buy

Budget wood router combo.

Reviews recommend this Skil woodworking router kit (with both a fixed and plunge base) as a great value if you only use a router occasionally. It has variable speed, but not a soft-start electronic speed control motor. It also lacks dust control (unless you buy extra accessories), and the collet system isn't as good as the ones on better-reviewed wood routers; one review says the collets have more runout (so the bit doesn't cut as precisely). The maximum depth is only 1.5 inches, but the Skil router does have a work-activated LED light, and it comes with a two-year warranty. (compare prices)
•  Bosch Colt PR20EVSK
   (*est. $120)

>> Where to buy

Trim router.

The Bosch Colt Palm Router gets high praise in more reviews than any woodworking router of this type (also called a laminating trimmer, though useful for routing wood). Comfortable for one-handed routing even for lefties, this lightweight 3.3-pound wood router comes with a self-releasing quarter-inch collet, variable-speed with electronic speed control and two-stage depth adjustment -- features usually found only on more powerful routers. It has a one-year warranty. (compare prices)
>>  Comparison Chart

Full Story
What the experts say, our analysis, and more...
Updated November 2007

Although wood routers can shape and cut soft metals as well as wood, we found the best comparison tests and reviews of routers in woodworking publications. Most recently, Popular Woodworking reviews nine router combo kits that come with both a plunge and fixed base, and Fine Woodworking tests wood routers for use in a router table. Trim routers, also called palm routers or laminate trimmers, get even more comparison reviews -- in Wood Magazine, American Woodworker and Woodworker's Journal.

At the other extreme, big 3-horsepower plunge routers are tested in Workbench magazine, Woodworker's Journal and Wood Magazine. All these wood-router reviews are based on objective tests, and Popular Woodworking even performs endurance tests over at least a two-year period. We also find useful information about wood router durability in owner-written reviews at Amazon.com and several other retailer sites.

Most new wood routers now use soft-start motors that keep the router from jerking out of control, and many add electronic feedback control (to keep speed steady even when the bit hits harder wood). Dust control and self-releasing collets are also becoming standard. For example, the Hitachi M12V2 plunge router (*est. $210), a budget pick in several reviews, adds dust collection and self-releasing collets to the well-reviewed Hitachi M12V. It's accumulating some complaints, however, in owner-written reviews at Amazon.com, for various quality control problems.

Warranty length can be a good indicator of overall quality, and whereas some product categories seem to have uniform warranty lengths, warranties among routers vary a lot between brands. Bosch, Craftsman, and Porter-Cable routers carry only one-year warranties, while Skil and Firestorm routers (both budget brands) carry two-year warranties. Triton, DeWalt and Festool warranties last three years, and Hitachi and Milwaukee router warranties last five. Only Ridgid offers a lifetime warranty.

Wood routers are the most versatile workshop tool. The basic concept is simple: Interchangeable cutting bits mounted on the shaft of a high-speed motor, which can make a wide range of tasks possible. Wood routers not only round or smooth edges, make grooves and cut simple hinge mortises, but they can also cut complicated joints, millwork or imitation lathe-turnings. Routers can turn plain wood into picture-frame moldings or tongue-and-groove flooring, in addition to other projects.  ... Continued

Consensus Report

Our Consensus Report shows how many times products are top-ranked by reviewers included in our
All The Reviews Reviewed chart.

# of picks Model (with retailer links) Details from Amazon.com
5 Hitachi M12V2 (*est. $210) details
4 Triton MOF001KC (*est. $200) details
4 Bosch 1619EVS (*est. $310) details
4 Freud FT2000EPK (*est. $190) details
3 Triton TRC001 (*est. $330) details
2 Festool OF 2000 E (*est. $430) -
2 Festool OF 1400 EBQ (*est. $400) -
2 DeWalt DW625 (*est. $240) details
1 each Craftsman 17517, DeWalt DW621 , Festool OF 1000 E (now the Festool OF 1010 E), Firestorm FS1200RP Ryobi RE180PL, Worx WT600K
# of picks Fixed-base Routers Details from Amazon.com
6 Milwaukee 5625-20 (*est. $275) details
5 Milwaukee 5615-21 Body Grip (*est. $155) details
3 Porter-Cable Speedmatic 7518 (*est. $340) details
3 Bosch Colt PR20EVSK trim router (*est. $120) details
3 Porter-Cable 9690LR (*est. $160) details
2 Makita RF1101 (*est. $200) details
2 Bosch 1618EVS (*est. $175) details
1 each Bosch 1617 , Craftsman 17542, Makita RD1101 , Milwaukee 4625-20, Porter-Cable 690 , Ryobi R161K
# of picks Combo Kit Routers Details from Amazon.com
5 DeWalt DW618PK (*est. $240) details
5 Bosch 1617EVSPK (*est. $220) details
5 Skil 1825 (*est. $100) details
4 Porter-Cable 895PK (*est. $270) details
2 Ridgid R2930 (*est. $200) -
2 Craftsman 26620 (*est. $200) -
2 Porter-Cable 693LRPK (*est. $170) details
2 Milwaukee 5616-24 (*est. $250) details
1 each DeWalt DW616PK

The Bosch 1619EVS is the top-ranked big plunge router, but recent reviews favor the smaller Triton MOF001KC if you don't need that much power, with the Hitachi M12V2 a budget choice. The two top-ranked Milwaukee fixed-base wood routers are also tops in reviews. Among combo kits, the DeWalt DW618PK is recommended in as many professional reviews as the Bosch 1617EVSPK, but has a longer warranty and fewer user complaints about breakdowns. The Bosch Colt PR20EVSK gets the nod among trim routers, also called palm routers or laminate trimmers.

Advertisement
Wood Routers Reviews