Movie Downloads and Rentals Reviews

Google
  Web ConsumerSearch.com   
Reviewing the Reviews Home Category Index Shop Newsletter Search About Us

Movie Downloads and Rentals Reviews

Updated March 2008

Best Movie Downloads and Rentals Reviews: (out of 25)
The New York Times, PC Magazine, The Washington Post

Best Movie Downloads and Rentals: (out of 25)
Netflix, CinemaNow, Vudu

Fast Answers - Best Movie Downloads and Rentals
Top Rated What the Research Says
•  Netflix
   (*est. $5 to $25 per month)

>> Where to buy

Best online movie rentals.

Most reviews choose Netflix over Blockbuster Online because Netflix has more movie titles (90,000 compared to 80,000) and more distribution centers (for quicker delivery). The two services outscore other mail-delivered rental services by a wide margin in every review we saw. Netflix also offers unlimited viewing of streaming broadband videos with all but the least expensive of its online DVD rental plans. DVDs are delivered by U.S. mail and return mailers are included. There are no late fees.
•  CinemaNow
   (*est. $3 to $4 each)

>> Where to buy

Best movie downloads.

Reviews say CinemaNow is the best option for renting movies by download to your computer (Windows XP and Vista only). CinemaNow offers about 4,500 titles and a real mixed bag of options. You can buy or rent movies. An extra-cost subscription (*est. $30 per month) gives members access to an additional 1,500 free movie downloads. Certain purchased movies can be burned to DVDs. Reports say that while the video quality of rented movies is fine, movies received via the subscription plan aren't of the same high picture quality. The drawback of movie downloads to a PC is that you'll need extra steps to watch movies on your TV rather than your computer. Rentals are only for a 24-hour period.
•  Vudu
   (*est. $300 for box plus $1 to $6 per movie)

>> Where to buy

Best set-top box for movie downloads.

Vudu connects to your TV and uses an Ethernet connection to deliver movies (you'll need a fast broadband connection). Not only do you enjoy the immediacy of the Internet, but you can also watch content on your TV instead of on your computer. Vudu's network uses peer-to-peer connections with other Vudu boxes to deliver movies faster. Reviews say Vudu outclasses previous set-top box solutions, but they are critical of the price of the box and the relatively small selection of movies – currently 5,000 titles with what some reviews call a lot of B-list filler. Rentals are for 30 days, with a 24-hour viewing period. Vudu has recently begun offering high-definition movie downloads.
>>  Comparison Chart

Full Story
What the experts say, our analysis, and more...
Updated March 2008

There are three kinds of online movie services. The first option involves online ordering from a vast inventory of DVDs that arrive via postal mail. Movie downloads streamed directly to your computer are another option. The third type of online movie rental uses an electronic box for receiving movies or other content over a broadband connection.

Ordering DVDs online remains the easiest and most popular way to receive movies. Most people still find streaming movies to a PC for viewing less than appealing. According to experts, issues include iffy video quality, limited selection and unattractive pricing. Viewing options are also not the best since transferring video files from a PC to a TV can be problematic; most users do not find the option of gathering the family around the computer screen to watch a two-hour movie very appealing. If you're the technical type, there are ways to network your computer and TV, but you'll need to spend money on compatible hardware and spend time on setup.

A third option -- streaming movie downloads directly to a set-top device -- is garnering a fair share of attention from reviewers, if not the public. These devices take many forms, including dedicated set-top boxes, digital video recorders with Internet capabilities and even videogame consoles. Downloading movies to a set-top box is clearly still in its infancy, but some experts are already predicting it could eventually replace the DVD and Blu-ray disc as a medium for rented movies. Among those is Bill Gates, who in an interview with USA Today said that direct movie downloads over broadband will eventually become "the dominant way that people get their movies." Others aren't so sure.

Given the attention movie downloads have been receiving of late, it is not too surprising that we found the best and most recent reviews for that form of online movie rentals. The New York Times, The Washington Post and PC Magazine all have good comparative articles fairly discussing the pros -- and cons -- of downloading movies directly to a set-top device. There are also a number of single-product reports at CNet.com, Macworld, PC World, Big Picture Big Sound and elsewhere. You can find reviews of DVD disc rental websites at TopTenReviews.com, SixStarReviews.com and other sites. DVDRR.com is a good spot to read user reviews of DVD rental sites.

The traditional DVD/Blu-ray online movie rental landscape is dominated by the two giants -- Netflix and Blockbuster Online. Still, a few niche and smaller sites, such as GreenCine -- which specializes in more esoteric foreign, art and indie titles -- continue to survive and even thrive. That said, user feedback from across the web seems to indicate that straying from the "big two" is not without some peril.

We saw a startling number of negative user comments for Intelliflix. That site -- originally known as DVD Barn -- had been the recipient of some positive press attention in the past for its value, offering an unlimited three-DVD-at-a-time plan for $10 a month if purchased for a year in advance. However, disc availability -- an issue with even the better known online movie rental sites at times -- appears to be a major problem. Users at DVDRR.com, Epinions and elsewhere are typically reporting unacceptably long delays -- sometimes months -- between receiving movies. Many users have also posted complaints regarding billing issues and poor customer service.  ... Continued

Consensus Report

Our Consensus Report shows how many times products are top-ranked by reviewers included in our
All The Reviews Reviewed chart.

# of picks Online Movie Rentals Company Estimated price
5 NetFlix (*est. $5 to $25 per month)
2 Blockbuster Online (*est. $4 to $35 per month)
1 each Anime Takeout, GreenCine, Jaman
# of picks Movie Download Services Company Estimated price
3 Vudu (*est. $300, plus $1 to $6 per movie or TV episode)
3 Xbox 360 (*est. $280 to $450, plus $2 to $6 per movie or TV episode)
3 Apple TV (*est. $230 to $330, plus $2 to $5 per movie or TV episode)
2 CinemaNow (*est. $3 to $4 per movie)
1 Amazon Unbox (*est. $4 per movie, $2 per TV episode)

Reviews say that Netflix and Blockbuster Online are competitive when it comes to online DVD rental. Netflix usually gets the edge because of its slightly larger collection. The two compete vigorously with each other on pricing and offer a variety of service plans, as well as ever-changing perks. CinemaNow is the best choice among movie services that stream to a PC. This kind of service provides you the convenience of faster delivery, but far fewer choices, and you'll have to either watch the movie on your computer or network your PC and TV screen. Critics say that Vudu is the best solution right now for those who want the convenience of watching downloaded videos on a TV, but that Apple TV might be the one to beat if it begins to offer more movies. The Xbox Live Marketplace is also worth considering if you own an Xbox 360 videogame console.

Advertisement
Movie Downloads and Rentals Reviews