Travel Sites Reviews

Google
  Web ConsumerSearch.com   
Reviewing the Reviews Home Category Index Shop Newsletter Search About Us

Travel Sites Reviews

Updated February 2008

Best Travel Sites Reviews: (out of 18)
J.D. Power & Associates, Kiplinger.com, Wired Magazine

Best Travel Sites: (out of 38)
Kayak, Hotwire, Vayama

Fast Answers - Best Travel Sites
Top Rated What the Research Says
•  Kayak
   

>> Where to buy

Best travel search engine overall.

An overwhelming majority of reviews say your first step in researching the best air, hotel, cruise and car rental prices should be a visit to Kayak.com. While sites such as Travelocity and Hotwire search only their own databases, Kayak searches over 140 airline websites, online travel agencies and other travel sites, including some international ones, to come up with its list of best fares. One interesting tool lets you see the best fares for similar routes found by other Kayak visitors. You can also get fare alerts and compare search results to other travel sites like Expedia.com. There are no booking fees.
•  Hotwire
   

>> Where to buy

Best for discount travel.

Hotwire maintains its own database of flight, hotel, car, package and cruise deals, and in a recent survey of over 5,000 travelers, Hotwire beats sites like Orbitz, Travelocity and Expedia in overall customer satisfaction. In addition to regular searches, Hotwire also offers further discounts if you choose one of its clearance fares. Though you don't know the airline, departure time or hotel name for these special fares until after you book, this can often save you $100 or more on flight bookings. If you're a flexible traveler, Hotwire is more likely to get you the lowest possible fare. One tool lets you choose the right time for a vacation based on historical pricing.
•  Vayama
   

>> Where to buy

Top search engine for international flights.

Vayama.com is a new travel site catering to international flights to 190 countries (you can also find domestic flights). The easy to use tools let you type in cities or click on a world map. There are helpful links to info on visas, passport requirements and health advisories, and excellent tools on getting around in your destination city -- including taxi and public transport options and pricing for getting from the airport into the city. Right now, you can't search for hotels on this new site; Vayama is for flights only. Booking fees vary by destination from $10 to $20.
•  Priceline
   

>> Where to buy

Best for deals on luxury hotels.

While Kayak.com and Hotwire.com both let you find hotel rates, Priceline gets special mention in reviews for its great deals on luxury hotels. The catch is that the Priceline's best deals are available through its bidding tool, where you specify desired price, location, hotel class and dates, but you don't know the actual hotel until after you've booked. Reviews say a bid of about $100 per night often gets you a great deal on luxury digs. One caveat is that locations sometimes span a considerable distance, so you might be somewhat removed from the most desirable spots, or from your business meeting. Experts advise that Priceline works well for last-minute travel, though.
•  Travelocity
   

>> Where to buy

Best for travel packages.

Although Travelocity isn't often mentioned in reviews as the best travel site overall, it does score extra points for packages, which bundle air, hotel and a rental car together, as well as last-minute packages. After upgrading its site recently, Travelocity also scores well in booking ease and website usefulness. There are no online booking fees for vacation packages, but make sure you understand the cancellation policy.
>>  Comparison Chart

Full Story
What the experts say, our analysis, and more...
Updated February 2008

We found lots of useful information about travel websites and travel search engines for this update. Research firm J.D. Power and Associates has published results of its survey of 5,414 people on customer satisfaction among travel websites, including Orbitz, Travelocity and Hotwire. Kiplinger and Travel + Leisure magazines name top sites based on the experiences of its authors and editors. Wired goes one step better by conducting identical searches on each site for specific scenarios. That's a testing tactic that many experts say you should try at home, since identical searches on multiple sites better your odds of finding the best airfare, car rental, cruise and hotel deals. Newspapers such as The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal and the Los Angeles Times give good ongoing coverage of travel websites and travel search engines.

Increasingly, hotels are undercutting travel websites by offering better deals on their own sites (as well as better cancellation policies and loyalty program awards). The same holds true for airfares. As a result, reviews often recommend checking the hotel's website directly, before booking through a travel site.

In reviews, experts say you should bypass sites such as Orbitz, Travelocity and Expedia, at least at first. Instead, start with a meta-search site like the top-rated Kayak.com or Yahoo! FareChase. Meta search sites scour airline and hotel websites, smaller databases and other travel sites to find low fares. According to reviews, Kayak.com is usually more likely to come up with an abundant list of lower fares and rates, especially for hotels. That's because search engines are more comprehensive in seeking the best price. Since they also check airline and hotel websites, you can book directly, skirting around the service fees usually charged by the large travel sites. In reviews, Kayak is easily the most well-rounded travel search engine, searching at least 140 different travel sites to come up with the best fares and hotel deals, so you’ll be sure not to miss a potential bargain. Kayak also has comprehensive fare comparison tools for checking prices at other sites and those paid by other travellers.

The most well-known travel sites are not recommended as often as Kayak.com in reviews. In a survey of 5,414 people conducted by J.D. Power and Associates, travelers indicated being least satisfied overall with Orbitz, which gets lower ratings again this year for site navigation and ease of use. When it comes to just booking hotels, the highly advertised Hotels.com earns only average scores from users. Users are happier with Hotwire for flight deals, and some experts say Priceline is the best travel site for nabbing deals on hotels -- particularly for deals on normally high-priced rooms in major cities.
 ... Continued
Consensus Report

Our Consensus Report shows how many times products are top-ranked by reviewers included in our
All The Reviews Reviewed chart.

# of Picks Model (With Retailer Links)
6 Kayak
4 Hotwire
2 Priceline
2 Mobissimo
2 Yahoo! FareChase
2 SideStep
2 Expedia
2 Travelocity
2 Orbitz
2 FareCompare
1 each CruiseCompete, SkyAuction, TripAdvisor, RealTravel, Gusto, LowesTravel, AirFare Watchdog, LuxuryLink, Vayama, Cruisemates, Cruisecritic

Most reviewers mention Kayak as the best option for beginning online searches for both air and hotel. But experts also like the Yahoo! FareChase and many suggest trying a search engine in conjunction with online travel sites such as Travelocity, Expedia or Orbitz. The reason: No single online search can turn up all the best fares. However, among the major travel sites, Hotwire gets the best reviews from travelers for overall customer satisfaction. Priceline gets the nod for hotel deals, particularly for deals on luxury hotels in major cities, but is a blind site so you won't actually know where you are staying until after you book a non-cancelable reservation. Priceline also has a standard search tool that doesn’t get as much attention in reviews. Mobissimo is recommended for international travel because of its relationships with overseas partners, but Vayama is a new up-and-comer for international travel that can book travel to 190 countries -- more than Mobissimo -- and it includes helpful information on visas and health advisories.

Advertisement
Travel Sites Reviews