String Trimmers Reviews

Google
  Web ConsumerSearch.com   
Reviewing the Reviews Home Category Index Shop Newsletter Search About Us

String Trimmers Reviews

Updated June 2008

Best String Trimmers Reviews: (out of 19)
Consumer Reports, Consumer Guide.com, Popular Mechanics

Best String Trimmers: (out of 35)
Black & Decker Grass Hog NST2018, Stihl FSE60, Craftsman 79197

Fast Answers - Best String Trimmers
Top Rated What the Research Says
•  Black & Decker Grass Hog NST2018
   (*est. $100)

>> Where to buy

Cordless grass trimmer.

If you mainly need to trim edges of a lawn (and not tall grass or weeds), experts and owners top-rate the 7-pound, cordless Black & Decker NST2018. This trimmer runs quietly and can last about 25 minutes per charge; two batteries are included, extending runtime to about an hour. Owners say this model works well on well-maintained lawns, but it's just not powerful or durable enough to handle weed whacking or tall grass. The Black & Decker trimmer comes with a two-year warranty. (compare prices)
•  Stihl FSE60
   (*est. $110)

>> Where to buy

Corded electric trimmer; better for weeds.

Although you still must contend with a cord, reviews say the Stihl FSE60 corded electric trimmer handles tough weeds and tall grass as well as most gas trimmers in the same price range, yet is lighter (8.7 pounds), quieter, easier to use and less polluting -- and you don't have to buy gasoline and oil for it. Owners praise it for quality and durability, and it can be used with a 200-foot extension cord. The Stihl comes with a two-year warranty.
•  Craftsman 79197
   (*est. $200)

>> Where to buy

Gas trimmer: most power, but heavy.

If you want the range of a cordless trimmer, yet need enough power to whack tall grass and weeds, reviewers top-rate the Craftsman 79197 gas trimmer. This four-stroke model runs quieter and is less-polluting than two-stroke models, and it doesn't require the mixing of gas and oil. Instead of bump-feed, this Craftsman trimmer uses lengths of precut line; owners say it's very easy to start and line refills are quick. The split shaft enables the use of optional attachments. However, the Craftsman trimmer weighs 20 pounds (without the gas), so you'll probably need a shoulder harness. Click Here!(check price at Sears)
•  Echo SRM-210
   (*est. $220)

>> Where to buy

Lightweight gas trimmer.

The Echo SRM-210 doesn't accept accessory attachments and isn't as powerful as the Craftsman 79197, but at 11.6 pounds, it weighs far less. Its 2-stroke engine requires that you mix oil with the gas, but reviews say this trimmer performs well. It uses short precut lengths of string, a feature that gets mixed reviews -- some owners love it and others hate it. If you want the power and range of a gas trimmer, but don't care about attachments, the Echo trimmer is easy to use and is lighter than most gas trimmers. (compare prices)
>>  Comparison Chart

Full Story
What the experts say, our analysis, and more...
Updated June 2008

String trimmers use electric motors or gasoline engines to rotate one or two thin nylon lines with such speed and force that they can cut grass, and sometimes weeds. Also called grass trimmers, line trimmers or weed eaters, these tools make trimming and edging a lawn much faster and easier than using hand tools like grass shears. The best string trimmers can handle tough weeds and tall grass along long fences, and keep a long driveway trimmed. String trimmers can also reach under shrubbery and cut grass in places too narrow for a lawn mower to reach.

We found the most recent comparison review at Consumer Reports, where editors rate and rank 44 string trimmers based on objective tests, including cutting tall grass and weeds. This year ten corded electric grass trimmers, along with three cordless models, are tested. However, the new Energy Star 36-volt Black & Decker NST2036 (*est. $300) cordless trimmer, designed to compete directly with gas trimmers, isn't tested. Only four of the gas string trimmers tested here feature the newer 4-stroke engines that are quieter and vibrate less than 2-stroke engines, as well as minimizing air pollution. Some gas trimmers using 2-stroke engines add carbon canisters to meet the latest emissions limits in force by the California Air Resources Board (CARB), but these models aren't noted in the report.

An older test of gas string trimmers at Popular Mechanics covers only 12 models, but includes some sturdier high-end trimmers and goes into more detail, especially about safety. ConsumerGuide's single-product reviews at ConsumerGuide.com are even more detailed and cover all three types of string trimmers: gas, cordless and corded electric. The reviews at all three sources evaluate each string trimmer over a short period of time under restricted conditions, so we supplement these tests with owner-written reports from homeowners and professional landscapers. These reviews often uncover problems other reviews couldn't find, and help to judge manufacturers' customer service as well.

Reviews say string trimmers made by Echo, Honda and Stihl stand out for performance and quality, but even within these brands there's significant variation among models. Consumer-level brands tend to rank lower, but reviews note some good buys. Worx is a relatively recent entrant to the power tool market, with its string trimmers getting better marks for ergonomics than for performance. The Swedish company Husqvarna makes string trimmers sold under the Craftsman, Husqvarna, Poulan and Weed Eater brands, with some models performing much better than others.

MTD makes Bolens, Cub Cadet and Troy-Bilt string trimmers, which are not known for durability but still can be good buys, at least in the short run. Homelite and Ryobi are owned by the same company, TTI Industries. We found some complaints about the durability of Black & Decker corded electric grass trimmers, but owners like the cordless Black & Decker trimmers, especially the 18-volt Black & Decker NST2018 (*est. $100) .  ... Continued

Consensus Report

Our Consensus Report shows how many times products are top-ranked by reviewers included in our
All The Reviews Reviewed chart.

# of Picks Electric string trimmers Details from Amazon.com
2 Craftsman 74534 (Discontinued) -
1 each Black & Decker 14 In. Auto Feed Grass Hog GH600 , Black & Decker GH1000 , Black & Decker ST7000 , Stihl FSE60, Toro 51353(now 51346) , Weed Eater 952-711767, Worx WG-103
# of Picks Cordless trimmers Details from Amazon.com
6 Black & Decker Grass Hog NST2018 (*est. $100) details
2 Black & Decker NST2036 (*est. $300) details
1 each Black & Decker CCC3000 kit , Black & Decker CST2000 , Ryobi P2000, Worx WG150
# of Picks Gas string trimmers Details from Amazon.com
2 Honda HHT25S 25cc 4-cycle (*est. $350) -
2 Click Here!Craftsman 79197 29cc 4-cycle (*est. $200) -
1 each Echo SRM210 or SRM210C , Husqvarna 125L (not CARB) , 25cc Poulan Pro PP125 , Shindaiwa T2510, Stihl HomeScaper FS 45 C Easy2Start, Troy-Bilt 31cc 41BDT20C966, Troy-Bilt 17" Straight Shaft TB70SS , Troy-Bilt Curved Shaft TB415 (4-cycle) , Troy-Bilt 17" Straight Shaft TB575SS 4-cycle , Weed Eater Featherlite SST25

Comparison reviews can only judge string trimmers based on performance and ease of use at the time of the test, so sometimes owner-written reviews turn up problems with long-term reliability, quality control or customer service. We take all this information into account in choosing the Fast Answers picks. Owners say, for example, that the Stihl FSE60 electric grass trimmer is built more durably than the Black & Decker GH1000. The Black & Decker Grass Hog NST2018 is the top-rated cordless model, despite mixed reviews for corded Black & Decker trimmers. Among gas string trimmers, the Honda HHT25S gets the best reviews, but this is an expensive professional trimmer. The Craftsman 79197 costs much less and also gets good reviews, but weighs 20 pounds.

Advertisement
String Trimmers Reviews