Trekking Poles Reviews

Google
  Web ConsumerSearch.com   
Reviewing the Reviews Home Category Index Shop Newsletter Search About Us

Trekking Poles Reviews

Updated June 2008

Best Trekking Poles Reviews: (out of 19)
BackpackingLight.com, Backpacker Magazine, Adventure Buddies.net

Best Trekking Poles: (out of 40)
Black Diamond Spire Elliptic, Gossamer Gear Lightrek 3, REI Summit

Fast Answers - Best Trekking Poles
Top Rated What the Research Says
•  Black Diamond Spire Elliptic
   (*est. $125 a pair)

>> Where to buy

Best trekking poles.

Reviewers rave about Black Diamond's unique locking system called FlickLocks that allows users to change length even in mid-stride or while wearing gloves -- helpful when the terrain changes. By contrast, other adjustable poles use twisting systems that require the use of two hands. The length adjusts from 41 to 55 inches, and the Spire trekking poles get good reviews for durability and comfort, with EVA handles. Their elliptical shape and 15-degree handle-tilt make them ergonomically sound. Spire trekking poles weigh 20 ounces per pair and come in a smaller size, the Spire Compact Elliptic (*est. $125), for those with smaller frames. (compare prices)
•  Gossamer Gear Lightrek 3
   (*est. $130 per pair)

>> Where to buy

Lightest trekking poles.

Most experts say adjustable trekking poles are best for most people, but some prefer fixed-length poles. These trade features and adjustability for light weight. Backpackers seem to universally love the carbon-fiber Lightrek 3, which weigh only five ounces per pair. They can be ordered in fixed sizes from 43.3 to 53 inches in length. The carbon fiber shaft dampens vibration, and although there's no strap, reviews say you won't miss it. The downside is that these trekking poles can snap under stress, or when the tip gets caught in a rock -- part of the tradeoff for the light weight.
•  REI Summit
   (*est. $60 per pair)

>> Where to buy

Budget trekking poles.

These budget REI trekking poles are basic. They don't have an anti-shock mechanism or positive-angle handles. REI uses rubber for the grips, which reviews say can get very slick when wet. Most experts say that you're better off springing for top-quality trekking poles, but if $100 or more is beyond your budget, the REI Summit poles are a good entry-level choice. These trekking poles are made of high-grade 7075 aluminum alloy, and they adjust from 25 to 55 inches with a total weight of 20 ounces per pair. (compare prices)
•  Leki Traveller
   (*est. $130)

>> Where to buy

Nordic walking poles.

Also called "fitness poles," this type of pole is used in a sweeping motion to involve the body more fully in walking, which burns more calories. These trekking poles are different than other types because they are meant to be released on the "backstroke." The top-rated Leki Traveller trekking poles adjust from 26 to 52 inches and come with demi-gloves that detach easily. Instructions on proper Nordic walking techniques are included. They come with a lifetime warranty against breakage. (compare prices)
•  REI Four Winds Travel Staff
   (*est. $80)

>> Where to buy

Travel hiking stick with camera mount.

Though reviews say a pair of trekking poles gives better balance and safety for hiking, some hikers prefer a single hiking staff (you only carry one pole). The REI Four Winds staff adjusts in length from 22.75 to 51 inches, so it can pack in standard 24-inch luggage. The wooden knob on top of the foam grip unscrews to reveal a universal camera mount, and the whole aluminum alloy hiking staff weighs just 8.5 ounces. It carries a lifetime warranty. (compare prices)
>>  Comparison Chart

Full Story
What the experts say, our analysis, and more...
Updated June 2008

Once used primarily by hikers, trekking poles are now being adopted by fitness walkers and those with disabilities. Studies show that trekking poles, hiking sticks and staffs improve balance and decrease lower-body stress – especially on the knees, while allowing users to burn more calories as they shift the stress to the body's core, providing a better cardio workout. Different types of poles have emerged to meet various needs: Rubber tips aid walking on pavement -- useful for fitness walking and physical rehabilitation -- while carbide tips help hikers and backpackers negotiate slippery trails and rocks. Poles that have half-gloves attached to the straps are useful in fitness or "Nordic" walking, which has become increasingly popular in recent years. Hiking sticks and trekking poles are especially important for balance at stream crossings; they also make steep descents faster and let the arms aid in steep uphill hikes. Trekking poles are used in pairs, while hiking sticks and staffs are used singly.

We found the best comparison review of trekking poles at BackpackingLight.com, which updated a 2005 report in 2006 by focusing on lightweight trekking poles made of carbon. Backpacking Light tested 12 carbon trekking poles, rating them on crucial safety factors that can prevent falls, as well as factors affecting comfort, like vibration dampening and tips that are easy to replace. Backpacker magazine includes reviews of ten trekking poles in its 2008 gear guide. Reviews are based on field tests, but trekking poles are not ranked.

The most thorough, in-depth trekking pole reviews can be found at BackpackGearTest.org, where individual hikers write lengthy field reports on gear, usually in three stages chronicling initial use up to long-term durability. However, since there's no standardized test or ratings system, it's hard to tell which trekking poles might be best overall. We also found good reviews on hiking and backpacking forums, as well as some anecdotal reviews at About.com and Outside magazine.

Some reviews are particularly helpful to hiking enthusiasts because they spotlight problem poles that malfunction when put under great stress, such as hiking on steep inclines or descents. For example, Backpacker magazine reports that lower-grade aluminum is more apt to bend, such as the aluminum used on the Mountainsmith Rhyolite 6061 trekking poles (*est. $50) ; one of these poles bent in a field test. A user at Trailspace.com also reports durability problems with this pole.
 ... Continued
Consensus Report

Our Consensus Report shows how many times products are top-ranked by reviewers included in our
All The Reviews Reviewed chart.

# of Picks Model (With Retailer Links) Details from Amazon.com
3 Leki Super Makalu Cor-Tec A/S PA (*est. $130) details
3 Black Diamond Spire (*est. $125 a pair) details
2 Gossamer Gear Lightrek 3 (*est. $130) -
2 Leki Traveller (*est. $130) -
2 Life-Link Guide Ultra-Light (*est. $100) details
2 Swiss Gear Hiking Pole (*est. $25) details
1 each Alpkit Carbonlite, Black Diamond Contour, Black Diamond Trail , EMS Women's Ridge Lite , Leki Super Makalu Ergometric A/S , Leki Ultralite Ti Ergometric A/S , Leki Wanderfreund , Life-Link Variant 3 AS, MSR Denali III , MSR Overland Carbon , REI Ascent Shocklight , REI Four Winds Travel Staff , REI Summit , REI Traverse , VIP Ski Walking Fitness Poles, Volkstaf

Leki and Black Diamond gets the most picks among adjustable trekking poles, and they cost about the same. We included the Black Diamond poles because we found such great enthusiasm for the FlickLock adjustment system on the Black Diamond poles. The fixed-length Gossamer Gear Lightrek Plus trekking poles are by far the lightest. Life-Link Guide Ultra-Light poles are relatively short, but rank at the top in comparative tests. We found mixed reviews for the budget-priced REI Summit and Swiss Gear trekking poles (and for all budget-priced poles).

Advertisement
Trekking Poles Reviews