Home > Family & Pets > Dog Food > Dog Food

Dog Food Reviews

By: Carl Laron on July 06, 2017

Editor's Note:
It's costly, but Orijen is the best dry food for your dog. Fromm makes a terrific canned food, while The Honest Kitchen makes a dehydrated food that experts and owners love. We found some great value choices as well, including a warehouse brand food that is surprisingly good.

Orijen Adult Dog Food Review
Best Reviewed
Specs that Matter Grain-free -- Yes Past recalls -- No Sizes (lbs.) -- 4.5, 13, 25

Best dry dog food

Orijen Adult Dog Food is expensive, but experts -- and dog owners -- say it's worth it. It's a high-protein, grain-free food made from fresh, locally sourced Canadian meats, eggs, produce and wild-caught fish. All preservatives are natural and protein sources are certified as being fit for human consumption. Orijen is made in a company-owned plant and the food has a spotless recall history. See our full review »

Buy for $93.65
Taste of the Wild High Prairie Review
Best Reviewed
Specs that Matter Grain-free -- Yes Past recalls -- 2012 Sizes (lbs.) -- 5, 15, 30

Best value dry dog food

It costs more than the dog kibble that can be purchased in your local supermarket, but experts say Taste of the Wild High Prairie is worth it: It's grain-free and soy-free, with no artificial preservatives. Buffalo meat is its top named ingredient, followed by lamb meal and chicken meal -- and there's even venison in the mix. It's not as meaty as Orijen, however, and the safety record, while good, is not quite spotless. See our full review »

Buy for $48.99
Kirkland Signature Review
Best Reviewed
Specs that Matter Grain-free -- No Past recalls -- 2012 Sizes (lbs.) -- 40

Best supermarket dog food

It's hard to find a quality dog food on the shelves of a supermarket or warehouse store, but Kirkland dry dog food (sold primarily at Costco) comes pretty close. It has an above-average meat content compared to its supermarket competition and, while the dog food is not grain-free, it mostly avoids the use of lower-quality grains. See our full review »

Fromm Family Gold Salmon and Chicken Pate Review
Best Reviewed
Specs that Matter Grain-free -- Yes Past recalls -- 2016 Sizes (oz.) -- 12.2

Best canned dog food

Experts say dogs should really eat wet food, and Fromm Family Gold illustrates why. It's grain-free and loaded with meat (USDA-approved, human-quality meat, at that), and with veggies, vitamins and minerals -- a simple recipe that's ideal for dogs, experts say. It costs less than other super-premium canned dog foods, too. See our full review »

Newman's Own Organics Grain Free Beef & Liver Review
Runners Up
Specs that Matter Grain-free -- Yes Past recalls -- No Sizes (oz.) -- 12

Organic canned dog food

Newman's Own Organics Grain Free Beef & Liver has a nutrient profile that mimics what a dog would eat in the wild. It's grain-free, and made mostly from USDA organic, free-range beef and liver. The food is GMO free and the beef comes from a country with strict regulations prohibiting the use of hormones and antibiotics. The icing on the cake is that Newman's Own costs less than many other premium dog foods -- and all profits go to animal charities.

Buy for $33.99
The Honest Kitchen Embark Review
Best Reviewed
Specs that Matter Grain-free -- Yes Past recalls -- 2013 Sizes (lbs.) -- 2, 4, 10

Best dehydrated dog food

You can get pretty close to a dog's wild diet with The Honest Kitchen Embark, reviews say. It's grain-free and, made from near-raw turkey and veggies. Embark comes in a convenient, dehydrated powder that you mix with water to make a moist food; a 10 pound box yields roughly 40 pounds of dog food. With all-natural ingredients and a strong safety program, this is a hands-down expert favorite. See our full review »

Buy for $95.05

There's a great dog food for any dog, or any budget

Dog food buyers are faced with a dizzying array of choices, and a host of contradictory -- and sometimes controversial -- -- claims over what the best diet is for their dog. This can lead to a lot of questions as to which food is the safest and most nutritious choice for their four-footed companions. And, of course, it has to be appetizing enough that Fido won't turn up his nose at dinnertime.

Types of Dog Food

Dry Dog Food

Kibble, or dry dog food, is convenient, and it costs the least per feeding (without water, it weighs less to ship and is a concentrated food source). Unlike cats, dogs will drink plenty of water to hydrate themselves, so dry food is perfectly acceptable. Just be careful: Most supermarket kibble consists mainly of corn and soy pellets -- not the meat that dogs evolved to eat, experts warn. High-meat, low- or no-grain kibbles are best. Experts say you should serve canned or fresh food, too, to make sure your dog gets enough moisture and protein. The cost of dry dog foods varies widely, from more than $3 per pound to as low as $1.10 per pound for good feeding choices.

Canned Dog Food

It's more expensive per feeding than dry dog kibble. but canned dog food is often high in meat and grain-free -- ideal for dogs, experts say. Expect to pay about $2 to $2.50 or more for a can of high-quality dog food. Canned food must also be handled more like a human's fresh foods. "Unlike kibble, wet foods exposed to the environment can easily grow bacteria — and quickly become contaminated," notes Mike Sagman at DogFoodAdvisor.com. For that reason, he adds, canned food should not be left in a dog's bowl for more than an hour or two, and any unserved dog food must be refrigerated -- and even then discarded after a couple of days.

Dehydrated Raw Dog Food

While some dog owners go the extra step of cooking for their dog, if you want a simpler way to feed Fido something that's closer to his or her wild diet, a dehydrated raw food is a good way to go. Raw or lightly steamed meats and veggies are dried and ground up; you add water to make a moist dog food. Expect to pay about as much per feeding as top-quality canned food. Raw dog food is also sold frozen.

Finding The Best Dog Food
Our Sources
"Dog Foods"
"Recalls & Withdrawals"

Pet-nutrition experts say that the best dog food is made from top-grade ingredients, especially meat and vegetables. While some high-quality whole grains are also acceptable, what you don't want is a lot of filler as the primary ingredient; these are items that have less nutritional benefit.

According to reviews, better-quality dog food results in a healthier coat, fewer digestive problems and firmer stools. Because your dog will absorb more nutrients from better-quality dog food, less will be passed as waste. You will also be able to feed less, closing the cost the cost gap between high quality food and cheap supermarket kibble.

Reading and understanding ingredient labels are the keys to finding top quality foods. We delve into what to look for in our section on dog food ingredients. Dog owners also have lots of resources to help them pick a safe, nutritious product. Sites and publications like PetsumerReport.com (and its companion blog, TruthAboutPetFood.com), DogFoodAdvisor.com, DogFoodGuru.com, DogAware.com and others put dog foods under the microscope, scouring labels for red-flag ingredients, demanding safety information and tracking recalls. Owner reviews are helpful as well, especially when it comes to learning which foods are eagerly eaten, and which ones leave our four-footed companions cold -- though keep in mind that a food that's heartily wolfed down by one dog might be completely rejected by another. Don't forget that your feline friends need a top quality food too, and we cover those in our separate report on cat food.

To find the top dry, canned and dehydrated dog foods we consulted the websites and publications named above and many more, and read thousands of user reviews. Based on that information, we looked first at ingredient quality and the safety of the food -- paying special attention to recalls, the reasons behind them, and how forthcoming dog food makers are with their customers. While every dog owner might like to feed their dog the best food available, not all have the budget to do that, so we also look to value to find choices that are close to the best, but cost less. The result? We found good dog foods for every budget, from Costco kibble to pricey "human food" dog food.

Recently Updated
Dog Food buying guide

What every best Dog Food has:

  • Complete nutrition.
  • Whole meat or a named meat meal as its top ingredient.
  • No fillers or low-quality grains.

Read More »

Learn More »