Home > Health & Beauty > Toothpaste > Toothpaste Sources

Top 12 Toothpaste Reviews

By: Angela Stringfellow on February 26, 2018

In this report

Sensitive Toothpaste Fluoride Free Toothpaste Our Sources

Toothpaste: Ratings of Sources

Editors of Reviews.com, April 26, 2017

After consulting with dental professionals and reviewing literature from the FDA and the American Dental Association, editors of Reviews.com select 18 toothpastes out of 200 options. Testers brush their teeth with each toothpaste for two minutes, evaluating each on taste, foaminess, packaging, and how their teeth feel after brushing, naming the best toothpaste for general use, the best whitening toothpaste, the best natural toothpaste, and the best toothpaste for sensitive teeth.

Contributors to Amazon, As of February 2018

Several of Amazon's top-selling toothpaste products have garnered hundreds, or even thousands, of reviews, and the website contains a wealth of information about customers' experiences. Nearly two dozen toothpaste products earn ratings of 4.3 stars or better in 350 reviews or more, including several natural toothpaste brands.

Contributors to Walmart, As of February 2018

While Walmart doesn't have as many toothpaste owner reviews as Amazon does, most of their products have at least a few dozen. Like Amazon, contributors rate toothpaste on a 5-point scale and can provide written feedback, although the reviews tend to be brief. More than a dozen toothpaste brands earn ratings of 4.1 stars or better in hundreds of reviews, while a few earn high ratings in thousands of reviews.

Contributors to Walgreens, As of February 2018

Walgreens is a popular destination for personal care products, and some toothpastes have earned hundreds of user reviews. Reviews tend to be fairly thorough, listing pros and cons and whether the owner would recommend the product to a friend. A few brands earn high ratings in thousands of reviews.

Mara Leighton, Jan. 10, 2018

Mara Leighton asks Beverly Hills-based dentist Dr. Neil Hadaegh, DDS to rank the five best whitening toothpastes. Each pick is accompanied by a summary (albeit brief) from Dr. Hadaegh explaining the benefits of each toothpaste, including details about the formulation, affordability, availability and other useful details.

Dr. David Evans, Not Dated

Dr. David Evans, DDS, recommends several different toothpastes for different needs based on his professional experience with patients in his practice. Toothpastes are recommended in several categories including the best whitening toothpaste, the best toothpaste for sensitive teeth, the best natural toothpaste, and the best toothpaste for people with braces.

Editors of GoodGuide.com, As of February 2018

Although the focus of GoodGuide is strictly environmental, it does contain useful information on the veracity of the claims of some "natural" brands, and its health scores are worthy of note. GoodGuide doesn't test products, but instead rates them based on the health and environmental risks of their ingredients; their methodology is meticulously detailed on their website. Toothpastes are rated on a 10-point scale on several criteria, but only one toothpaste and one tooth powder earn a perfect 10-star rating.

Sarah Smith, Not Dated

After testing 44 toothpastes, Sarah Smith lays out her top eight picks in eight different categories, including Best Foam, Best Innovation, Best Overall, Pro's Healing Pick, Best Botanical, Best Whitening, Best for Sensitive Teeth, and Best On-the-Go. Smith doesn't disclose her testing methodologies or the criteria used to determine the winners, although she does appear to have consulted a periodontist.

Marissa DeSantis, Not Dated

Marissa DeSantis recommends the best toothpastes based on reader reviews at TotalBeauty. Overall, seven toothpastes are recommended, including whitening toothpaste, toothpaste for sensitive teeth, and a few natural toothpaste options. Each recommended toothpaste is described in a short paragraph, including feedback from TotalBeauty readers.

Editors of Men's Health, Nov. 14, 2017

Editors of Men's Health recommend the best toothpaste for men based on opinions from a panel of dentists. Toothpastes are recommended in several categories, including the best all-around toothpaste, best natural toothpaste, the best toothpaste for mouth health and the best toothpaste for sensitivity.

Erika Stadler, Jan. 8, 2018

Erika Stadler talks to "celebrity" dentists -- cosmetic dentists and other dental professionals who have treated famous actors and musicians -- to get their recommendations on the best whitening toothpaste. Overall, 16 whitening toothpastes are recommended, including widely available drugstore brands as well as some lesser-known, pricier options.

Editors at Cleveland Clinic, March 9, 2015

Cleveland Clinic's family health editors talk to Hadie Rifai, DDS for expert advice on how to choose the best toothpaste for your needs. He recommends choosing a toothpaste with at least 1,000 parts per million of fluoride with the ADA stamp of approval. For people with sensitive teeth, he says over-the-counter toothpaste for sensitive teeth is a good starting point, but if they don't alleviate your sensitivity, there are prescription options available from dentists.

Recently Updated
Toothpaste buying guide

What every best Toothpaste has:

  • Tartar-fighting abilities.
  • Enamel protection.
  • Non-irritating, safe ingredients.

Read More »

Learn More »