If breakfast just seems off to you when there isn't a plate of toast within close reach, you know how important a good toaster is for creating those perfectly crunchy, golden brown slices. And because it's one of those countertop appliances you'll use almost daily, it's important that you find a toaster that suits your needs perfectly. But with so many on the market and so many great brands, like Hamilton Beach and Cuisinart, to choose from, how do you even get started?
We'll walk you through some of the best options available today, taking into consideration important features and stylistic elements like slot widths, warming racks, finishes and overall size to help you gain a deeper understanding of what'll work well for you. Breakfast is about to get so much tastier!
Best Overall: CUSIBOX Stainless Steel Toaster
There are many toasters available, but the CUSIBOX Stainless Steel Toaster may be the greatest thing since sliced bread. You can toast four slices at once, and individual control dials allow you to customize your toast. It’s easy to use and easier to clean and comes in three fashion colors. Nearly 75 percent of reviewers give it five stars for its speed, functionality, and construction.
Best Value: Amazon Basics 2 Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster
For a quality toaster at a great price, check out the Amazon Basics 2 Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster. With this toaster, you can choose from one of six browning settings for toast the way you like it. Extra-wide slots allow you to toast bagels and larger slices of bread. Buyers gave this toaster five stars for even cooking and sides that stay cool.
Best Space-saver: Bonsenkitchen 2-slice Black Toaster
If space is a premium in your kitchen, the Bonsenkitchen 2-slice Black Toaster is the one for you. It takes up less space on the counter. You don’t have to sacrifice function for space because seven browning settings let you toast your bread the way you want it. Reviewers rave about how evenly this toaster heats bread as well as how quickly it toasts.
Best Retro Design: Nostalgia RTOS200AQ Bagel Toaster, 2-Slice
If funky retro design is your thing, you’ll love the Nostalgia Bagel Toaster. This toaster looks like it arrived straight from the 1950s, but don’t let the old-school looks fool you. Wide slots and five browning settings put you in control of the toasting. Three-fourths of reviewers gave this toaster five stars for both fun design and functionality.
Best Leverless Toaster: Cuisinart CPT-440 Touch to Toast Leverless 4-Slice Toaster
The Cuisinart CPT-440 Touch to Toast Leverless 4-Slice Toaster is one of the most advanced toasters available. The LCD counts down when your toast is ready, but the most remarkable feature is the leverless design. You don’t have to worry about fishing out a piece of toast when it doesn’t pop up. More than 1,000 reviewers give it five stars for its impressive operation.
Best Long Slot Toaster: IKICH 4 Slice Long Slot Toaster
Do you need something bigger than a regular-sized toaster slot? The IKICH 4 Slice Long Slot Toaster is here to help. You can toast larger slices of bread, waffles or four slices of bread with this generous-sized toaster. Unlimited possibilities are in your hands. Almost 75 percent of reviewers rave about the even cooking and the versatility of this toaster.
Best Multitasker: Hamilton Beach Toastation Oven with 2-Slice Toaster Combo
Multitasking is the name of the game with the Hamilton Beach Toastation Oven with 2-Slice Toaster Combo. It’s both a traditional toaster and a small toaster oven. You can cook more than just bread with this beast ― from baking pizza to reheating leftovers, you can count on this toaster to do it all. Around 2,000 reviewers give it five stars for its functionality and versatility.
Best Warming Rack: Hosome Stainless Steel Bread Bagel Toaster
When is a toaster more than just a toaster? When it’s the Hosome Stainless Steel Bread Bagel Toaster. This toaster gives you amazing control, including defrost and reheat functions and a bagel setting. The most impressive feature is the warming rack, which allows you to keep bread warm without toasting it. An impressive 88 percent of reviewers give it five stars for practicality and convenience.
Most Innovative Design: Oda Kitchen Long Slice Toaster
For decades, toasters have had slots on the top where your toast pops out. The Oda Kitchen Long Slice Toaster changes the way you think about toasters with its innovative pull-out tray. It’s safe, easy to use, and more versatile. You can toast bagels, bread and sandwiches. Around 65 percent of reviewers give this toaster five starts, citing how evenly it toasts all types of bread.
Best No-frills Toaster: Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster
You’ve seen plenty of toasters with unique features, but what if you’re looking for a basic toaster? Meet the Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster. You don’t have to worry about features you’ll never use or confusing settings. All you get with this toaster is toast just the way you want it. Buyers love the wide slots and the simplicity of this no-frills toaster.